Everyone tells you to niche down. So you do. Then you niche down again, and again, until there is nobody left to sell to.
I’ve watched founders do this for years. They think a smaller audience means a better business. Usually it just means a smaller business.
Here is how I think about niche, mission, identity and brand in 2025, and why you can grow wide with purpose instead of shrinking yourself out of the market.
Quick answer: How do I choose a profitable niche without shrinking my market?
Pick a specific offer, not a tiny audience. Over niching kills your market. My fitness business targeted men and women aged 35 and up, broad on purpose. Grant, a former physical therapist, helps physical therapists build in person businesses and did $600,000 last month. Build around a mission, give your brand an enemy, and win two platforms or fewer.
- A specific offer beats a specific audience; my fitness business targeted men and women aged 35 and up.
- Build your brand around a mission, with a clear identity and an enemy.
- Organize your content into two to four content buckets.
- Focus on two platforms or fewer; mine are YouTube for long form and Instagram Reels.
- Tell your founder story; I grew up in a family of seven kids with a teacher for a dad.
What is the over niching trap?
Here is how it usually goes. You start with moms. Then moms aged 30 to 35. Then moms with dogs. Then moms with dogs and Crohn’s disease. Then moms with two kids on top of all that.
By the end, there is nobody left.
The lesson is simple. Be specific in your offer, but don’t get so narrow with your audience that you exclude yourself from the market.
When I ran my fitness business, the offer was “eat whatever you want without sabotaging your results.” The ads and content went to men and women 35 and up who were tired of yo yo dieting. That was broad enough that someone with two kids, or no dog, could still buy. The offer did the narrowing, not a long list of demographics.
Why does a specific offer beat a specific audience?
Two of my clients show this well.
- Grant is a former physical therapist who helps physical therapists build in person businesses. He did $600,000 last month. His background builds instant trust with the exact people he serves.
- Cynthia earns over $100,000 a month helping kids get into Ivy League colleges. Her niche is unique by the offer alone.
If you are in a crowded market like fitness or business consulting, you can still get specific without pricing yourself out. Serve only trainers. Or only people who want to eat a vegan style diet. One clean cut is enough.
Build around a mission
My first company, the fitness business, wasn’t mission driven. I was mainly trying to make money. That’s normal, but it has a ceiling.
I grew up in a family of seven kids. My dad was a teacher and earned just enough to get by. That drove me to change my own life.
Today my mission is to help people make more money so they can leave the rat race and do what they want, when they want, with who they want. I call that true freedom.
Why money? Because extra income pays for the things that fix everything else. Therapy, nutrition, a trainer, a business consultant. I can’t personally help everyone, but I can give people the means to help themselves.
Give your brand an identity and an enemy
Once you have a niche and a mission, step three is building an identity. People will react to it, positively or negatively. Your job is to make as much of that reaction positive as you can.
An identity works best with an enemy to push against:
- Fitness business: the identity was flexible eating, enjoying life and staying in shape. The enemy was rigid, overly structured diets.
- Business consulting: the enemy is “the matrix,” the 9 to 5 job and the ordinary life. It isn’t bad. It’s just the thing we push against.
In college I set a goal of $100,000 a month. A mentor told me that wasn’t a lot of money. After more than seven years in business, I now earn hundreds of thousands a month.
The identity I project is hard work, discipline, family, never giving up, and valuing experiences over Lamborghinis, cars and houses. The people who share those values become clients I enjoy working with, and they are the ones most likely to succeed.
Why is brand the play in 2025?
Building a brand is probably the most important thing you can do this year.
I’ve spent over $30 million on ads, and they drove a lot of my growth. But ads are a roller coaster. Organic content works the same way, except for most people it just stays low.
Free views are equivalent to money. I believe the next wave of billionaires will be people who combine a strong brand with a good business strategy. That’s why I post consistently, test new formats, hire staff for content and ideation, and pay consultants to get better.
Map your content into buckets
Pick two to four content buckets that reflect what your audience responds to. That gives people predictable content, with variety inside it.
- One on one breakdowns with business owners. These may get fewer views, but they show expertise. I want to do more of them.
- Digital products. These go more viral and appeal to a broad audience. One of my digital product videos has 132,000 views. I shot it five months ago and it keeps pulling views.
- A third bucket I’m still testing. One on one consulting videos filmed at my home have also done well.
Tell your founder story
People respect founders who share their struggles and how they got through them. Without an origin story, people may not respect what you’ve accomplished.
My story points are simple. Humble beginnings. Dad was a teacher, mom stayed home. Six siblings. I earned scholarships for college and bought my own car. That no BS background attracts a certain kind of person.
Compare that to a billionaire’s son. No matter what he builds, people give the credit to his father.
Don’t make your life harder on purpose. But if you’ve overcome something real, that story builds your brand and pulls in your ideal customers.
Pick two platforms and win them
LinkedIn, Facebook, Snapchat, TikTok, Instagram, YouTube. You can’t post everywhere at once and do it well.
My focus is YouTube for long form and Instagram Reels. We repurpose that content to the other platforms. Native content for LinkedIn, TikTok and Twitter would perform better, but I haven’t mastered YouTube and Instagram yet, so I’m not spreading thin.
Focus on two platforms or fewer until they grow. Trying to run seven or eight on your own gets you minimal progress everywhere.
The takeaway
- Get specific with the offer, not with an endless list of audience traits.
- Build around a mission that means something to you.
- Create an identity with a clear enemy so the right people lean in.
- Treat your brand as an asset, organize content into buckets, and tell your founder story.
- Win two platforms before you add more.
Frequently asked questions
Is it bad to niche down too far as an online coach?
Yes. Over niching shrinks your market until there aren’t enough buyers. Make the offer specific instead of the audience. My fitness business targeted men and women aged 35 and up, which is broad, but the offer was clear. Cynthia earns over $100,000 a month helping kids get into Ivy League colleges. Clear result, big market.
How many social media platforms should a coach focus on?
Two or fewer. You have six main options: LinkedIn, Facebook, Snapchat, TikTok, Instagram and YouTube. Trying to win all of them spreads you thin. I focus on YouTube for long form and Instagram Reels. Win two platforms first before you think about the rest.
What are content buckets for a personal brand?
Content buckets are the few themes you rotate your posts through so your audience knows what you stand for. I recommend two to four buckets. Map every piece of content to one of them, and tie them back to your mission and your founder story so the brand feels consistent.
Why should a personal brand have an enemy?
An enemy gives people something to rally against and makes your identity clear. Your brand needs a mission, an identity and a clear thing you stand against. That is why brand is the play in 2025: people buy from founders they identify with, not from faceless offers.
Why does a founder story matter when selling online?
Your story is what makes people trust you over someone with the same offer. I grew up in a family of seven kids with a teacher for a dad. In college I set a goal of $100,000 a month. After more than seven years in business, I earn hundreds of thousands a month. Share where you started.
Want to know what’s capping your business right now? Take my free 90 Day Ceiling Plan. Answer 18 questions and get a written plan, built on your own numbers, that names the one thing holding you back and what to fix first.
Written by Tanner Chidester, founder and CEO of Elite CEOs. He has done over $150M in sales, worked with 50,000+ clients, and hosts the Infinite Income Podcast.






